Take advantage of a second opinion

(855) 750-5757
Contact
Blog

How to Find the Best Shoulder Surgeon

Posted on: February 27th, 2025 by Our Team

Choosing the right shoulder surgeon is a critical decision that can significantly impact your recovery, functionality, and long-term health. Whether you’re dealing with a rotator cuff tear, shoulder instability, arthritis, or another complex shoulder condition, selecting an experienced, compassionate, and skilled surgeon is essential to achieving the best possible outcome. This guide outlines the key factors to consider when choosing a the best shoulder surgeon for your condition.

Verify Credentials and Training

When selecting a shoulder surgeon, it’s essential to confirm their credentials. The most qualified surgeons are board-certified in orthopedic surgery and have completed fellowship training in shoulder surgery or sports medicine. This specialized training ensures they are proficient in the latest surgical techniques and treatment approaches for complex shoulder conditions.

A surgeon with this level of training can handle a wide range of cases, from minimally invasive arthroscopic procedures to complex open surgeries. As one of the leading shoulder surgeons in the Detroit area, Dr. Ben Mayo is fellowship trained in orthopedic sports medicine with a focus on minimally invasive and complex open shoulder surgery. His extensive training ensures patients receive the most up-to-date and effective treatments available.

Assess Experience and Specialization

Experience is a crucial factor in achieving successful surgical outcomes. Higher volume surgeons who perform shoulder procedures regularly develop a deeper understanding of shoulder anatomy and pathology, which often translates into better results. It’s important to inquire about how many similar procedures the surgeon has performed and how frequently they treat your specific condition.

A skilled surgeon should have extensive experience with various shoulder conditions, including rotator cuff tears, shoulder instability, and arthritis. Dr. Ben Mayo specializes in shoulder surgery and performs hundreds of shoulder surgeries each year, ranging from minimally invasive repairs to complex reconstructions and replacements. His broad experience allows him to tailor treatment plans to each patient’s unique needs, ensuring optimal outcomes and faster recovery times.

Review Patient Testimonials and Reputation

Patient reviews and testimonials provide valuable insights into a surgeon’s communication style, bedside manner, and overall patient satisfaction. While no surgeon can guarantee perfect results, consistently positive feedback from previous patients can be a strong indicator of quality care.

Dr. Mayo’s patients frequently highlight his compassionate approach, thorough explanations, and ability to make them feel heard and respected. His high ratings on platforms like Google and Healthgrades reflect his commitment to patient-centered care and long-term success. Hearing firsthand accounts from patients who have undergone similar procedures with Dr. Mayo can provide peace of mind when making your decision.

Consider Communication and Personal Comfort

Choosing a shoulder surgeon isn’t just about technical skill—effective communication is equally important. You should feel comfortable discussing your concerns, and your surgeon should take the time to explain your diagnosis, treatment options, and what to expect during recovery.

Dr. Ben Mayo places a strong emphasis on patient education and shared decision-making. Oftentimes there is no one right answer for a problem. He believes that informed patients are empowered to make the best choices for their health. During consultations, Dr. Mayo takes the time to listen to your concerns, answer your questions, and develop a treatment plan that aligns with your goals and lifestyle. His approachable demeanor helps patients feel at ease, which is essential when facing medical decisions.

Don’t Hesitate to Seek a Second Opinion

Seeking a second opinion is an important part of making an informed decision about your healthcare. A skilled and reputable shoulder surgeon will welcome second opinions and should never pressure you into making a rushed decision regarding surgery. Taking the time to explore all options ensures that you’re confident in your treatment plan. For some conditions, surgery is the recommended first line treatment, but many shoulder conditions can improve with medications, physical therapy, and injections and can avoid surgery.

Dr. Ben Mayo encourages patients to seek second opinions when considering surgical or non-surgical options. He understands the importance of being fully informed and comfortable with your decision. Dr. Mayo is committed to transparent communication and patient autonomy, offering comprehensive information about potential treatments and answering all questions without rushing the decision-making process. When appropriate, he is also open to referring patients to other qualified specialists to ensure the best possible outcome and that you are comfortable with the recommended plan.

Evaluate the Surgical Facility and Support Team

The quality of the surgical facility and the supporting care team plays a significant role in your overall experience and recovery. Accredited facilities with state-of-the-art technology and experienced medical staff contribute to safer procedures and better outcomes.

Dr. Mayo performs surgeries at top-rated, accredited facilities in Livonia and Sterling Heights, ensuring patients have access to the best surgical technology and safety standards. His dedicated team—including nurses, medical assistants, and physical therapists—works closely with patients before, during, and after surgery to provide comprehensive care. This coordinated approach helps streamline the process and ensures you receive the support you need at every stage of your recovery.

Understand Treatment Options and Philosophy

A top-tier shoulder surgeon should offer a full range of treatment options tailored to your unique situation. Not every shoulder condition requires surgery; conservative treatments such as physical therapy, medication, and injections may be effective in many cases. However, when surgery is necessary, the surgeon should be experienced in both minimally invasive and open surgical techniques.

As one of the best shoulder surgeons in the Detroit area, Dr. Ben Mayo believes in a patient-first approach. He thoroughly evaluates each patient’s condition and considers all nonoperative options before recommending surgery. When surgery is indicated, Dr. Mayo is proficient in a multitude of techniques, including minimally invasive arthroscopic procedures and more complex open reconstructions. This versatility allows him to select the most appropriate treatment for your specific condition and lifestyle.

Inquire About Recovery and Follow-Up Care

Recovery from shoulder surgery is a crucial part of the treatment process. A great surgeon will provide a clear plan and be involved in post-operative care, including physical therapy, follow-up appointments, and guidance on safely returning to your normal activities. Successful recovery depends on both the quality of the surgery and the rehabilitation process that follows.
Dr. Mayo develops individualized recovery plans for each patient, ensuring that rehabilitation is tailored to their goals and the specifics of their surgery. He works closely with a network of physical therapists to guide patients through the recovery process and ensure that strength, flexibility, and shoulder function are fully restored. Regular follow-up appointments are scheduled to monitor progress and adjust the treatment plan as needed.

Why Dr. Ben Mayo is the Right Choice for Your Shoulder Care

Finding the best shoulder surgeon involves careful consideration of credentials, experience, communication, and comprehensive care. Dr. Ben Mayo meets and exceeds these standards, offering patients in the Detroit area the highest level of expertise and personalized attention. His commitment to patient education, surgical excellence, and ongoing support ensures that you’re in good hands from your initial consultation through your recovery.

Serving communities across Detroit, including Troy, Bloomfield, Canton, Macomb, Farmington Hills, and Novi,, Dr. Mayo provides convenient access to top-tier shoulder care at his Livonia and Sterling Heights offices. Whether you’re seeking non-surgical solutions or require advanced surgical intervention, Dr. Mayo has the expertise and compassion to guide you through every step of your journey. Take the first step toward recovery. Contact us today to schedule your consultation at our Livonia or Sterling Heights offices and experience the difference compassionate, expert care can make.