Take advantage of a second opinion

(855) 750-5757
Contact
Blog

How to Find the Best ACL Surgeon

Posted on: February 27th, 2025 by Our Team

If you’ve been diagnosed with an ACL (anterior cruciate ligament) tear or think you might have injured your knee, choosing the right surgeon is one of the most important decisions you’ll make in your recovery journey. ACL reconstruction is a complex procedure that requires a surgeon with specialized training, extensive experience, and a patient-centered approach. Selecting the best ACL surgeon can make the difference between returning to your previous activity level and facing long-term complications. In this post, we’ll explore the key factors to consider when searching for an ACL surgeon.

Specialization in Sports Medicine and Knee Injuries

When it comes to ACL reconstruction, you want a surgeon who is an expert in sports medicine and has extensive experience treating knee and ligament injuries. ACL tears are common among athletes but can happen to anyone, and the surgical repair requires precise technique to restore stability and prevent future injury. Dr. Ben Mayo is fellowship-trained in orthopedic sports medicine, with a focus on treating complex knee injuries, including ACL tears. His advanced training ensures that he stays up-to-date with the latest surgical techniques, including all-inside ACL reconstructions, graft options, biologic augmentation such as the Bridge Enhanced ACL Repair (BEAR) procedure, and advanced fixation methods to provide the best outcomes for his patients.

Volume and Experience Matter

Studies consistently show that surgeons who perform a high volume of ACL reconstructions tend to have better patient outcomes. Experience matters not only in performing the procedure but also in recognizing nuances during surgery that can impact recovery and long-term knee stability, as well as which patients do not need surgery. As an expert knee surgeon, Dr. Mayo performs a high volume of ACL reconstructions annually, treating patients ranging from recreational athletes to those competing at collegiate and professional levels. His extensive experience allows him to tailor surgical techniques to each patient’s specific anatomy and activity goals, helping them safely return to their desired level of activity.

Personalized Treatment Plans and Graft Selection

Not every ACL tear is the same, and neither is every patient. Factors such as age, activity level, and future sports participation should influence the surgical plan, including the surgery type (repair or reconstruction), and choice of graft (e.g., patellar tendon, hamstring, quadriceps tendon, or allograft). Some surgeons follow a “one size fits all” approach where everyone gets the same graft or same technique. Dr. Mayo believes in a personalized approach to ACL surgery and is very comfortable performing every option. During your consultation, he discusses the pros and cons of each graft option and considers your lifestyle, sports participation, and recovery goals when recommending a treatment plan. This individualized approach ensures the best long-term outcome for each patient.

Focus on Rehabilitation and Full Recovery

Surgery is just one part of the ACL recovery process. Rehabilitation plays a critical role in restoring strength, mobility, and stability to the knee. An experienced surgeon will collaborate with physical therapists and provide a comprehensive post-operative plan. Staying up to date on current evidence is critical. Some surgeons will offer a faster recovery and promise a quick return to sport in 6 months. While this may sound appealing, there is extensive literature to support not returning to sports until 9 months after surgery to prevent re-injury. Returning to sports before 9 months can have up to a 7x risk of reinjury. Dr. Mayo works closely with physical therapists throughout the Detroit area to create evidence based rehabilitation protocols to minimize the chance of another ACL tear. His commitment to long-term success ensures that patients don’t just recover from surgery but regain the confidence and strength to return to their favorite activities.

Communication, Patient Education, and Shared Decision-Making

Undergoing ACL reconstruction can be overwhelming. A great surgeon takes the time to explain the diagnosis, treatment options, and recovery expectations in clear terms. You should never feel rushed into surgery or confused about the process. Dr. Mayo is known for his patient-centered approach and clear communication. He encourages patients to ask questions and takes the time to explain every step of the process, from pre-surgery preparation to recovery milestones. His goal is to ensure you feel informed and confident in your care decisions.

Technology and Surgical Techniques

Advancements in ACL surgery have improved outcomes, reduced recovery times, and minimized complications. Surgeons who utilize modern techniques, such as anatomic ACL reconstructions, extra-articular and biologic augments, and minimally invasive approaches, often provide better long-term results. Dr. Mayo employs the latest technology, including arthroscopic techniques and individualized graft placement, to restore the knee’s natural anatomy. His attention to detail ensures optimal knee stability and reduces the risk of re-injury, helping patients achieve long-lasting results.

Importance of Second Opinions and Informed Choices

Choosing to undergo surgery is a significant decision. A skilled and ethical surgeon will encourage you to explore your options and seek second opinions when necessary. You should never feel pressured to make a quick decision without fully understanding the benefits, risks, and alternatives. As one of the best knee surgeons in the area, Dr. Mayo welcomes second opinions and is committed to helping patients make informed choices about their care. His focus is on what’s best for the patient, ensuring that you feel confident and comfortable with your treatment plan.

Why Dr. Ben Mayo Should Be Your Choice for ACL Surgery

When it comes to ACL reconstruction, experience, communication, and a patient-focused approach make all the difference. Dr. Ben Mayo combines advanced training, extensive surgical experience, and a compassionate approach to provide exceptional care for patients throughout the Detroit area. From your initial consultation to your full return to activity, Dr. Mayo is committed to guiding you every step of the way.

Serving communities including Troy, Canton, Rochester, Farmington Hills, Novi, and Bloomfield, Dr. Mayo offers convenient locations in Livonia and Sterling Heights to make quality orthopedic care accessible. If you’re facing an ACL injury and exploring your options, don’t leave your recovery to chance. Contact Dr. Ben Mayo’s offices to schedule a consultation and take the first step toward getting back to the activities you love.

Your knee deserves expert care—and Dr. Mayo is here to provide it.